4 Questions to Better Mental Health
I’ll show you how four simple questions can help you loosen the grip of hopeless, anxious, or self-loathing thinking.
We’ve all had those days. You make a mistake, or several, and suddenly your mind offers up a hopeless idea:
“I’ll never get this right. I’m hopeless.”
It lands like a punch to the chest. Heavy. Final. Unquestioned.
But what if you did question it?
In Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy (REBT), we learn that many emotional struggles, such as anxiety, depression, shame, or rage, don’t come from the events in our lives alone, but from our inflexible attitudes about them. These attitudes often go unchallenged, but they don’t have to.
REBT gives us the easy-to-use, simple tool called disputation: the practice of questioning the beliefs and attitudes that cause our distress.
Note: It’s not about being positive or pretending you feel great! Instead, it’s about asking honest, grounded questions that cut through the inflexible thought processes that drive damaging emotions like depression and anxiety.
Let’s look at four simple disputation questions you can use—applied to one very common attitude:
“I’ll never get this right. I’m hopeless.”
- What’s the evidence for or against this attitude?
- Would reasonable people agree with this attitude?
- Would I teach this attitude to a child or friend?
- Is this attitude helping me?
- Why This Works
- Final Thoughts
1. What’s the evidence for or against this attitude?
REBT starts with data. If you were arguing a case in court, what would you bring? Just feelings? Or facts?
Ask yourself:
What proof do I actually have that I’ll never get this right?
Have I struggled before and still improved?
Is there any evidence that I can learn or change?
You might find that the attitude isn’t built on evidence but rather that it’s built on a feeling of discouragement.
You’ve had setbacks, yes but does that equal lifelong hopelessness? Probably not. In fact, once you start evaluating evidence, you may well find that there is overwhelming evidence that you can and have in fact struggled and improved before!
This question helps you counter emotional reasoning: the habit of believing something is true just because it feels true.
2. Would reasonable people agree with this attitude?
Let’s imagine someone else or a group of people watching you say, “I’ll never get this right. I’m hopeless.”
Would they nod in solemn agreement? Or would they say something like:
“You’re being too hard on yourself.”
“Learning takes time.”
“No one gets it right the first time or all the time.”
This question helps you step out of your mental echo chamber. What sounds absolute and obvious in your head often looks exaggerated from the outside.
This disrupts the illusion of certainty that often fuels anxiety and depression. You learn to question the imagined ability to predict the future or know things 100%, all of the time.
3. Would I teach this attitude to a child or friend?
Picture a child you care about struggling with something new. They look up at you and say, “I keep messing up.” Would you say,
“Well, you’ll never get it right. You’re hopeless.”
Of course not.
You’d likely say:
“It’s okay to struggle. You’ll get there.”
“You’re not hopeless—this is just hard right now.”
This question softens the tone. It helps you apply the same compassion and reason to yourself that you’d offer someone else.
It’s a shortcut to emotional fairness, a way to notice how cruel and unbalanced our internal attitudes can be compared to how we treat others.
4. Is this attitude helping me?
Even if “I’ll never get this right, I’m hopeless” felt convincing, REBT asks the most practical question of all:
Is this helping me move forward?
Does this motivate me, or make me want to give up?
Is it fuelling action or paralysis?
If the attitude leads to shame, inaction, or avoidance, then it isn’t useful, no matter how familiar it feels.
REBT believes in helpful thinking, not magical thinking. If a belief is making life harder, it’s worth replacing, even if it once felt “true.”
Why This Works
You don’t need to shout affirmations in the mirror. You don’t need to pretend everything’s fine. But you do need to be honest with your thoughts and not just passively accept them because they sound familiar or dramatic.
By asking the four questions above, you can begin to dismantle the attitudes that keep you stuck and replace them with ones that support growth, effort, and emotional resilience.
Final Thoughts
REBT teaches that emotional health isn’t about having “perfect” thoughts. It’s about choosing thoughts that are realistic, flexible, and constructive.
So next time your mind serves you a harsh judgment, pause. Ask a question.
Dispute it like a curious, kind, slightly skeptical friend.
That’s how you argue your way into clarity, courage, and calm.
Marcel is a qualified Psychologist (Counselling), based in Melkbosstrand, Cape Town, South Africa.
With a commitment to mental health, Mr Harper provides services in English, including Psychotherapy.
Mr Harper has expertise in Addiction, Anger Management Issues, Anxiety Disorders, Burnout, Depression, Divorce and/or Separation, Gay, Lesbian and Same Sex Counselling, Procrastination and Relationship Counselling.
Click here to schedule a session with Mr Harper.
Important:
TherapyRoute does not provide medical advice. All content is for informational purposes and cannot replace consulting a healthcare professional. If you face an emergency, please contact a local emergency service. For immediate emotional support, consider contacting a local helpline.
Find a Therapist
Find skilled psychologists, psychiatrists, and counsellors near you.
