Choosing the Right Therapist: What Really Matters

Your path to healing starts with the right partnership.

Over the years, I've come to rely on a simple but effective practice when starting therapy. When someone first gets in touch, I suggest starting with one to three sessions. These early meetings are exploratory: I listen closely to understand what's brought them in, while they clarify what they hope for from therapy.

Just as importantly, it gives them a chance to see whether working together feels right. At the end of this stage, we pause, reflect, and decide on the next steps. When there's an early sense of connection, it often signals meaningful work ahead.

What I've found in practice reflects what decades of research confirm: finding the right therapist isn't just about credentials or techniques - it's about relationship.

Table of Contents | Jump Ahead

• Why the Connection Matters Most
• The Three Pillars of Connection
• What Really Predicts Success
• What to Look For (and What Matters Less)
• Your Selection Strategy
• Making Your Decision
• When to Switch
• Taking Your Next Steps
• Crisis Resources
• References

---

Why the Connection Matters Most

Here's what might surprise you: the most comprehensive analysis involving nearly 200 studies and over 14,000 patients shows that the therapeutic relationship accounts for more of therapy's success than the specific approach used¹.

According to this study, the strength of your relationship with your therapist explains about 27% of whether therapy works for you. Researchers consider anything above 20% to be a medium-sized effect - meaning it makes a real, noticeable difference in people's lives.

Even more striking, how well you connect in just your third or fourth session can predict how successful your entire experience will be.

Key Insight: The quality of your working relationship is more predictive of success than whether your therapist practices cognitive-behavioural therapy, psychodynamic therapy, or any other specific approach.

The Three Pillars of Connection

Strong therapeutic alliances come down to three core components²:

• Emotional bond – that sense of trust and safety that develops when you feel truly understood. In my experience, this is the foundation of any meaningful change.
• Goal agreement – clarity about what we are working toward. When we’re aligned on goals, the work becomes focused and purposeful.
• Task agreement – understanding how we’ll work together. This includes the approach we take in sessions, what methods or reflections we use, and how we track progress. When there’s clarity here, the process feels collaborative rather than confusing.

For me, paying attention to these three areas early on helps ensure that the therapy relationship is strong, safe, and effective.

What Really Predicts Success

In-depth analysis revealed something important: how the therapist shapes the connection drives the success of therapy. More effective therapists formed strong alliances across different patients³.

This offers hope for anyone worried about being "too difficult" for therapy. Patient characteristics didn't predict outcomes as expected - even patients with difficult histories could benefit significantly. The determining factor was the therapist's ability to form alliances with challenging clients.

What to Look For (and What Matters Less)

Based on the research:

Prioritise These Qualities

• Strong Connections: Look for therapists who ask about previous experiences, talk about therapeutic fit, and explain how they handle bumps in the relationship. Ask: "How do you know if we're working well together?" "What do you do if a client feels we're not connecting?"
• Genuine Flexibility: The best therapists recognise when they're not the right fit, address issues directly, and refer clients elsewhere when appropriate⁴.
• Cultural Understanding: Seek someone experienced with your background and aware of how culture shapes therapy¹.
• True Empathy: Therapists who understand your experience, communicate it, and use it to guide support¹.

What Matters Less Than Expected

• Type of Therapy: Different therapy approaches often have similar results¹. What matters most is how well the therapist delivers it and how it fits with you.
• Years in Practice: Effectiveness depends more on the individual therapist than on experience. Even newly licensed therapists with strong training can be very effective.
• Credentials: Fancy degrees don’t guarantee better results. Look for proper licensing, solid training, and the ability to build a strong connection.

Your Selection Strategy

The Three-Session Test: Alliance typically forms within the first few sessions. Evaluate fit after three sessions:

• Session 1: Focus on comfort and feeling understood
• Session 2: Notice if the therapist remembers details and builds on previous conversations
• Session 3: Assess whether you feel hopeful about the partnership

If you’re not feeling some progress by session three, consider discussing it with your therapist (their response can be very informative) and exploring other options.

Shop Around: Consult with two to three therapists before deciding. This allows you to compare approaches and make an informed choice rather than settling.

Red Flags: Trust your instincts if a therapist seems consistently distracted, you don't feel heard after several sessions, they're frequently late or disorganised, you feel judged rather than supported. Also, be cautious if they push specific approaches without considering your preferences, make promises about quick fixes, or seem inflexible about adapting methods.

Making Your Decision

Prioritise what you have learned about the therapist in this order: connection-building, cultural awareness, professional skill, therapy approach, then practical factors like location and cost.

While evidence provides important guidance, your subjective experience matters. Pay attention to whether you feel comfortable and safe, understood and respected, hopeful about the partnership, and whether the therapist’s explanations make sense.

When to Switch

Acknowledging poor fit and making changes is good self-advocacy, not failure. Share your concerns with the therapist first.

Consider switching if you've given the relationship four to six sessions without feeling connected, you're not seeing progress after a reasonable time, your therapist can't understand your perspective, you consistently feel worse after sessions, or your circumstances change.

Taking Your Next Steps

Start by identifying your priorities using these evidence-based factors. Find therapists who specialise in your concerns, prepare consultation questions, schedule meetings with two to three candidates, and give yourself permission to take time deciding.

Finding Therapists: Check insurance for covered providers, ask your doctor for referrals, contact professional organisations, use reputable online directories, and consider asking trusted people for recommendations while remembering that fit is individual.

If Cost is a Concern: Explore community mental health centres with sliding scale fees, university training clinics, employee assistance programmes, online therapy platforms, and ask therapists directly about sliding scale availability.

Taking these steps thoughtfully sets the stage for therapy that helps you explore, gain insight, and build the confidence to navigate life more effectively.

When you’re ready, you can reach out via the button below.

Crisis Resources

If you're experiencing thoughts of self-harm or suicide, seek immediate help by calling emergency services, contacting a crisis helpline, going to your nearest emergency room, or reaching out to a trusted person.

• Crisis Support
• Emergency Medical

References